Print
Email
>
>
Syria Debate Reflects Danger Of Delaying F-35 Program
Recent
Tags
14 Ohio-class SSBNs 2011 budget 2012 Election 450 Minuteman III ICBMs 50/50 737 787 787 Dreamliner A&D A2/AD A320 A330 AA/AD AAV ABL Abram Acquisition Reform Acquisitions ADAS ADS Advanced Distributed Aperture System Advanced Hawkeye AEA Aegis AEHF Aerostat AESA Afghan surge Afghanistan Agility Aging Air Fleet AgustaWestland AH-1Z Air Defense Air Dominance Air Force Air Force Modernization Air France Air Logistics Center Air Logistics Centers Air Mobility Air National Guard Air Power Air Superiority Airborne ISR airborne laser airborne surveillance Airbus Aircraft Carrier Aircraft Carriers Airlift Airpower AirSea Battle Al Qaeda Alliances Alliant Techsystems Allies Alternate Engine Al-Yamamah American Enterprise Institute America's Future Ammunition Industrial Base Amphibious amphibious warfare AMPV AMT Anniston Anti-Access Anti-Access/Area Denial Apache APL ARFORGEN ARG Armored Vehicles Arms Control Arms Sales Arms Transfers Army Arnold Punaro Arrow Ashton Carter Asia Asia- Pacific Asia-Pacfic Pivot Asia-Pacific Asia-Pacific Pivot Asia-Pacific Region Asia-Pacific Strategy Assymetric Warfare AT-6 ATK AUSA Austal Australia AW609 AWACS B-52 Babcock & Wilcox BAE Systems BAE-EADS bail out Bain Capital BAMS Barack Obama Barbero Bath Iron Works BBP BCA Bechtel Beechcraft Benghazi Better Buying Power Bin Laden Bio-Engineering Biofuel Biohacker Biotechnology Black Hawk Blackhawk Bloomberg Bloomberg Business News BMD BMDR Boeing Bombers Boston BRAC Bradley Bradley Fighting Vehicle Britain British Military British Ministry of Defense Brookings Institution Brown budget Budget Control Act Budget Debate Budget Deficit Budget Drills Byron Callan C-130 C-17 C-2 C-5M CAPE Cargo Containers Cargo Screening Carrier Strike Group carriers CENTCOM Central Africa CH-47 Chabraja Chief Executive Officer China Chinook helicopter Chuck Hagel CIRCM climate change closing tank plant Cluster Bombs Cluster Munitions Coast Guard Collaborative Defense Comanche helicopter Commercial Space Common Infrared Countermeasures Common Vertical Lift Support Platform Communications Competitive Engagement Competitiveness Computer Sciences Corporation Concurrency Conflicts of Interest Congress Consolidation Constellation Contingency Support Contractors Continuing Resolution Contract Services Contracting Core Corzine cost Counterinsurgency Counterterrorism CRH Critical Enablers Critical Infrastructure Crowdsourcing Crusader artillery CSAR CTF Customer Pay CVLSP CVN CVN-78 CVN-91 Cyber cyber attack cyber defense cyber offense Cyber Security Cyber Threats Cyber Warfare Cybersecurity Cyberwar Cyberwarfare DARPA DB-110 DCAA DDG 1000 DDG-1000 DDG-51 debt Debt Agreement Defense Acquisistions Defense Acquisition System Defense Acquisitions Defense Budget Defense Business Board Defense Contract Requirements Defense Contractors Defense Contracts Defense Cuts Defense Downturn Defense Drawdown defense funding cut Defense Industrial Base Defense Industry Defense Planning Defense Priorities Defense Procurement Defense Sector Defense Spending Defense Stocks Defense Strategy Defense Weather Satellite System deficit Deficit Debate Deficit Reduction Delta Delta Air LInes Democrats Democrats & Defense Department of Defense Depot Depot Maintenance Depots Deputy Secretary Of Defense deterrence Detroit Arsenal Tank Plant DHS Dick Cheney Diversification DLA DOJ Donald Rumsfeld Dong Feng Dreamliner Drive down cost Drone Drones DRS Technologies DWSS DynCorp E-2 E-2D E-3 EA-18G EADS EASE Economic Growth Economic Recovery Economy Efficiency Drive Efficiency Initiative EFV Egypt EH101 EH-101 Elections Electric Grid Electric Power Grid Electronic Attack Electronic Warfare EMARSS energy security Energy Strategy Environmentalism EOTS EPA EPAA Erin Moseley ERP EU euro crisis Europe European Union eurozone EW Excaliber Exelis Ex-Im Bank Expeditionary Fighting Vehicle Export Controls Export Financing Export-Import Bank F/A-18 F117 F-15 F-16 F-22 F-35 F-35 engine F-35B FAA Fairfax County Fajr 5 rocket FCS Federal Reserve Fighter Sales Fincantieri Finmeccanica Fire Fighting Fire Resistant Environmental Ensemble fiscal cliff FMS FMTV Force Posture Force Protection Force Readiness Force Structure forcible entry Ford class Foreign Arms Sales Foreign Military Sales Forest Service Franco-British security FREE free speech Free Trade Future Combat System Future Combat Systems future warfare Gaddafi Gadhafi GAO Gates Gaza GBI GCV GE GEN III General Dynamics General Electric General Martin Dempsey General Mattis General McChrystal General Odierno General Schwartz GFE GISP Global Hawk Global Influence Global Strike Global Zero GMD GMR Goldman Sachs Gordon England Gorgon Stare Government Accountability Office GPS III Great Britain Greece Greyhound Ground Based Interceptor Ground Combat Vehicle Ground Mobile Radio Gun Control guns versus butter Hagel Hal Rogers Hamas Handheld Manpack Radio Hapag-Looyd HASC Hawker Beechcraft Hawkeye Healthcare Helicopters Heritage Foundation HH-60G High-Speed Rail HMS Homeland Defense Homeland Security Homeland Security Air Fleet Hu Jintao Human Spaceflight Humvee Huntington Ingalls Hybrid Drive Hybrid Strategies Hybrid Threat Hybrid Threats hybrid warfare Hypersonic Hypoxia ICBM IED Immelt Improvised Explosive Devices Incremental Funding India Industrial Base Industrial Policy Inherently Governmental Insitu Insourcing installations abroad Integrator Intellectual Property Intelligence Community IR&D Iran Iran Sanctions Iraq Iron Dome ISR Israel IT Providers ITT ITT Corporation ITT Defense J-20 Jacksonville Jammer Jammers Japan Jay Johnson Jay L. Johnson Jeffrey Immelt Jet Engines JFCOM JIEDDO JLENS JLTV Jobs Bill Joint Chiefs of Staff Joint Forces Command Joint Heavy Lift Joint Operating Environment Joint Stars Joint Strike Fighter Joint Tactical Radio System Jones Act JSTARS JTRS KBR KC-45 KC-46 KC-X Kent Kresa Kiowa Kiowa helicopter Korea L-3 Communications LAAR Lake City Larry Prior LAS LCAAP LCS LEMV Leon Panetta Libya Lieberman Life Cycle Costs Light Air Support Lima Lima Army Tank Plant Linda Gooden Linda Hudson lithium-ion batteries Littoral Combat Ship Lockheed Martin Logistics Long Endurance Multi-Intelligence Vehicle (LEMV) LRS LUH Lynn M1 M-1 Mabus Maersk maintenance MANPAD ManTech manufacturing Marillyn Hewson Marine Corps Marine Highway Initiative Marine One Marines Marinette Maritime Transport Mars Massachusetts M-ATV McNerney MDA MEADS MECV merger MEU MH-60 Michael O'Hanlon Middle East Middle East Unrest Mid-term election Military Military Communications military cuts Military Depots Military Electronics Military Pension Military Preparedness Military Readiness Military Retirement System Military Satellites Military Space Military Spending Military Strategy Military Vote Mine Countermeasures Mine Warfare Missile Defense Missile Defense Agency Missile Security Missile Tracking Satellite Mitt Romney MMPDS Modernization MPC MQ-9 MRAP MRC MRO Multiyear Contract Multiyear Procurement MV-22 NABCO NASA National Defense National Guard National Intelligence Estimate National Military Strategy National Research Council National Security National Security Appropriations Bill National Security Review National Security Strategy National Taxpayer Union NATO Navistar Navy Navy Acquisitions Navy Marine Corps Intranet Navy SEAL Navy SEALS NCADE NDAA Net Assessment NETCENTS Network-Centric Warfare Networks New Mexico New START Next Generation Enterprise Network Next Generation Jammer NGEN Nick Chabraja NIE NIFC-CA Nigeria NII Nimitz class NLOS-LS NLRB NMCI NMD Non-Proliferation Norm Dicks North Korea Northrop Grumman November Election NPR NRO NSA nuclear Nuclear Detection Nuclear Deterrence Nuclear Energy Nuclear Power Nuclear Reduction Nuclear Shipbuilding Nuclear strategy nuclear triad Nuclear Weapons Nunn-McCurdy O&M Obama Obamacare Odierno Office of Air and Marine OH-58 Ohio Ohio Class Ohio Replacement Oil O'Keefe OMB Operations and Maintenance Osama bin Laden Oshkosh Oshkosh Corporation Osprey Outsourcing overheating P.W. Singer P-8 P-8A PAA Pacfic Pacific Pakistan Panetta Partner Capacity Partnering Patriot Pave Hawk PBL Pentagon Pentagon Budget Pentagon Cuts Pentagon Spending PEO Soldier Perchlorate Performance Based Logistics Performance-Based Agreement Performance-Based Logistics Persian Gulf Phalanx Phased Adaptive Approach Phased Adaptive Architecture Pilot Training PLA Navy Poseidon Pratt & Whitney Predator Presidential Helicopter Private Contractors Procurement PSSD PTSS Public Interest Research Group Public Private Partnership Public-Private Partnership Public-Private Partnerships Pyongyang QDR QHSR Raider Rapid Equipping Force Rapid Fielding Initiative Rare Earth Ray Mabus Raytheon Readiness Reaper Rebalancing Reconnaissance Helicopter Reelection REF Regulatory Burden Republicans Reset Restart F- 22 RFI Richard Aboulafia Rifleman RIMPAC Rivet Joint RMD 802 Robert Gates Robert O. Work Robert Stevens Rocket Industry Rocket Motors Rocketdyne Rolls-Royce Romney Ron Epstein RPV RQ-170 RQ-4 RQ-7 Rules of Engagement Russia S-300 S-97 SAIC Samsung satellite Satellites Saxby Chambliss SBINet SBIRS Scan Eagle Seapower Secretary Donley Secretary Gates Section 808 Sentinel Sequestration Shadow ship building Shipbuilding Should Cost Methodology Sierra Nevada Sierra Nevada Corporation Sikorsky Situational Awareness SLAMRAAM SM-3 Smart Defense Smart Defense Initiative SOF Soft Power Solar Electric Propulsion Soldier As A System Soldier Equipment solid rocket motor SOSCOE South Korea Space Space Based Infared System space disaggregation Space Launch Space Shuttle Space Tracking and Surveillance Satellite SpaceX Space-X Special Operations Special Operations Forces SSBN SSBN(X) Standard Missile Standard Missile 3 START START Treaty Stealth Helicopter Steel Strait of Hormuz Strategic Architecture strategic arms control Strategic Arms Treaty Strategic Review Stryker STUAS submarine Submarines Subsidies Super Committee Super Galaxay Super Hornet Supply Chain Supply Chain Management Sustainable Defense Sustainment swing states Switchblade Syria T-38 T-38 Trainer Tactical Communications Taiwan Taliban Tanker Tankers Tea Party Teal Group Technical Data terror terrorism Testing Requirements Textron THAAD The Economist Theater Express Tiltrotor Tilt-rotor TLSP Trade Deficit Trade Policy Trade Subsidies Transformation Trident Trident submarine Troop Reduction Turkey Tysons Corner U.K. U.N. Investigation U.S. Army U.S. embassy in Cairo U.S. Manufacturing U.S. Navy U.S. Strategy U-2 UAS UAV UAVs UCLASS UH-1Y UH-60 UK United Kingdom United Technologies Unmanned Aerial System Unmanned Aerial Systems Unmanned Aerial Vehicles unmanned air systems (UASs) Unmanned Aircraft Urgent Operational Needs US Ports US101 USFS USS Missouri Utah V-22 V-22 Osprey Vertical Lift Virginia Virginia-class submarine WAPS war War On Terror WARN Washington Weapons Programs Weapons Spending Wes Bush WGS White House Transparency Measure Wichita Wideband Global Satcom Wikileaks William Perry WIN-T World Trade Organization WTO Yemen York
<< Previous
Next >>

Syria Debate Reflects Danger Of Delaying F-35 Program


Over the last several years, the Obama Administration has repeatedly delayed and restructured the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter program, arguing that more time was needed for testing before the program could enter high-rate production. One consequence of the delays has been to raise the cost of each plane, which potentially will impair the capacity of foreign partners to purchase it. The administration says the inefficiencies associated with depressing production rates can be made up later, and it doesn't want to ramp up until it can be certain there will be no need to go back and correct problems that might be found in early production planes.

That argument is a little misleading, because the reduced production rate persists after testing is scheduled to conclude, suggesting part of the motivation for delays is just to save money. But that's not the big problem with waiting to get F-35 into the force. The main problem was on display this week in congressional hearings, when Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Martin Dempsey warned lawmakers about how capable Syrian air defense are. According to Dempsey, Syria's surface-to-air missiles and surveillance radars are denser and more advanced than those that Libya possessed, meaning any campaign to bomb the brutal dictatorship of President Assad would be a tougher operation than efforts launched last year in support of Libyan rebels.

Syria's air defenses wouldn't matter much if the U.S. military had a large force of stealthy tactical aircraft, because radars wouldn't be able to track them and missiles wouldn't be able to target them. But there are only a handful of such planes in the force today, and at the rate F-35 is progressing that will remain the case for some time to come. All three military services destined to operate the F-35 have delayed the plane's operational debut in response to program restructures, and with the slow ramp-up in production rates, it will be two decades before the stealthy strike aircraft are fully fielded. That's a long time to wait in a world that periodically confronts policymakers with unexpected threats.

So the real danger with delaying high-rate production of F-35 isn't that the price of each plane will go up, but that the nation might find itself unprepared to deal with a future adversary. The problem wouldn't be so bad if the administration hadn't terminated the only other stealthy tactical aircraft the U.S. had in production, the F-22 fighter, but now the F-35 is the only game in town in terms of future production. It also is better configured for the kind of ground attacks that proponents of bombing Syria favor than the F-22, which was conceived mainly to assure dominance of hostile air space. That's why F-35 is called a "strike" fighter -- because it was designed to perform both air dominance and surface attack missions. But it can't do those things if it isn't fielded, and right now the Pentagon is exhibiting no sense of urgency about getting the plane into the force.

The leisurely pace of administration plans for fielding F-35 is emblematic of the recently unveiled Asia-Pacific posture, which calls upon the nation to make the sacrifices necessary to do what it wanted to do anyway (get out of Afghanistan). The new posture abolishes the traditional two-war sizing construct for conventional forces, eliminates the capacity to conduct protracted counter-insurgency operations, and suggests further reductions in the strategic nuclear force. Development of a new ballistic-missile submarine to serve as the backbone of the future nuclear deterrent is delayed two years, which like the delays in F-35 reflects little concern about future threats. Maybe it will all work out differently than when the Bush Administration made the same kind of optimistic assumptions on the eve of the 9-11 attacks. But there's a saying in the Pentagon that "the enemy gets a vote" in the development of future strategy, and right now that reality seems to be missing from F-35 plans.

Loren B. Thompson, Ph.D.

Return to Early Warning Blog
<< Previous
Next >>
1600 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 900
Arlington, VA 22209
P: 703-522-5828 | F: 703-522-5837
©2009 Lexington Institute. All Rights Reserved.
Website designed by Borcz:Dixon | Powered by Agency of Record